Halloween Who is Most Likely
The Perfect Party Game for Giggles, Surprises & a Whole Lot of Spooky Fun
If you’ve ever wrangled a group of sugar-charged kids, tried to get teenagers off their phones, or simply wanted something easy, low-prep, and actually fun for your Halloween get-together this one’s for you.
Let me introduce you to one of our all-time favorite party games: Halloween Who’s Most Likely To. It’s silly, surprising, and sparks the kind of laughter that turns a good party into a great one. Plus, it works for all ages from the little pumpkins to the “I’m only here for the snacks” teens (and even the grown-ups who just came for the wine and candy).
Whether you’re hosting a classroom party, a family Halloween night, or a costume bash with friends, this game is your secret weapon. No complicated instructions, no fancy props just a printout or a list on your phone and you’re good to go.
What Is “Who’s Most Likely To”?
“Who’s Most Likely To” is a classic get-to-know-you game that puts a Halloween twist on everyday scenarios. One person reads out a question like, “Who’s most likely to eat all the candy before Halloween?” and everyone points (or votes) on who in the group fits the description best.
There’s no winner. No pressure. Just laughs, playful teasing, and a chance to see your family and friends in a whole new light often with ridiculous and hilarious results.
Why It’s Perfect for Halloween Parties
Honestly? Because it’s:
- Effortless – You don’t need to buy a single thing.
- Inclusive – Great for mixed ages; just tweak the questions to suit your crowd.
- Bond-building – People open up, joke around, and get silly together.
- Flexible – Works just as well for 5 people as it does for 25.
Plus, it pairs beautifully with a big bowl of popcorn and leftover Halloween cookies.
How to Play Halloween Who’s Most Likely To
Let’s keep this easy-peasy:
What You’ll Need:
- A printed list of questions or one phone/tablet with the list pulled up.
- A way to vote: pointing, paper slips, candy corn tokens whatever works!
- A group of friends or family ready to play (4 or more is ideal).
How to Play:
- Sit everyone in a circle or around a table.
- One person reads a question aloud from the list (feel free to take turns).
- Everyone in the group points to or says the name of the person who they think is most likely to fit the prompt.
- Optional: Let the chosen person explain themselves if they want to this is where the funniest stories come out.
- Move on to the next question and repeat!
You can play for 10 minutes or keep going until your cheeks hurt from laughing.
Halloween “Who’s Most Likely To” Questions
Ready to get started? Here’s a mix of family-friendly, spooky-silly questions you can use. Some are geared toward kids, some are perfect for teens or adults mix and match to suit your crew!
Fun for All Ages:
- Who’s most likely to eat all their Halloween candy in one night?
- Who’s most likely to win a costume contest?
- Who’s most likely to get scared in a haunted house?
- Who’s most likely to dress their pet in a costume?
- Who’s most likely to trip over their costume?
- Who’s most likely to sneak candy when no one’s looking?
- Who’s most likely to be mistaken for a real zombie?
- Who’s most likely to dance to the Monster Mash?
- Who’s most likely to carve the best pumpkin?
- Who’s most likely to forget to buy Halloween candy and panic at 5pm?
Silly & Spooky (Kid-Friendly):
- Who’s most likely to believe ghosts are real?
- Who’s most likely to scream the loudest during a scary movie?
- Who’s most likely to hide behind the couch during a spooky scene?
- Who’s most likely to dress up as a banana just to be funny?
- Who’s most likely to get lost in a corn maze?
- Who’s most likely to try and scare everyone else?
- Who’s most likely to wear the same costume as last year?
- Who’s most likely to start a candy trading war?
- Who’s most likely to name their pumpkin?
- Who’s most likely to tell the best spooky story?
For Teens (and Tweens Who Think They’re Teens):
- Who’s most likely to post their costume on TikTok before leaving the house?
- Who’s most likely to go trick-or-treating even if they say they’re “too old”?
- Who’s most likely to wear a costume just for the candy?
- Who’s most likely to end up on a viral Halloween fail video?
- Who’s most likely to flirt with someone dressed as a vampire?
- Who’s most likely to throw the best Halloween party?
- Who’s most likely to coordinate a group costume (and boss everyone around)?
- Who’s most likely to prank their friends on Halloween?
- Who’s most likely to have a Halloween playlist ready in July?
- Who’s most likely to bail last-minute because “they didn’t have the right outfit”?
For Grown-Ups (You Deserve Fun, Too):
- Who’s most likely to steal candy from their kid’s stash?
- Who’s most likely to forget it’s Halloween until the doorbell rings?
- Who’s most likely to get way too into their costume?
- Who’s most likely to eat the “decoration” cupcakes before the party starts?
- Who’s most likely to accidentally scare a trick-or-treater?
- Who’s most likely to light the pumpkin but forget to scoop it out first?
- Who’s most likely to bring wine to the school Halloween event?
- Who’s most likely to still be in costume on November 2nd?
- Who’s most likely to make Halloween cocktails that are way too strong?
- Who’s most likely to say “this year I’m not decorating” and then go all out?
Tips to Keep It Lighthearted and Fun
Here’s where the mom-who’s-seen-it-all wisdom kicks in:
- No teasing allowed. The game’s meant to be silly, not hurtful. If something hits a nerve, skip it.
- Adapt the questions. Got a super young crowd? Keep it tame. Got older kids? Sneak in a little sass.
- Keep it short if energy dips. Don’t be afraid to stop while the fun’s still high.
- Get everyone involved. Even the shy ones. Sometimes the quietest person has the funniest answer.
- Play it again later in the night! It’s a great second-round game after snacks and costume contests.
Make It Even More Fun (Optional Twists!)
Want to turn it up a notch? Try these:
- Candy Voting – Give everyone a pile of candy corn and have them toss one into a cup in front of the person they’re voting for.
- Write Your Own Questions – Let guests add their own “Who’s Most Likely To” questions to a bowl and draw them at random.
- Costume Tie-Ins – Award bonus candy if the person voted for is actually wearing something related to the question (e.g., zombie outfit for “most likely to survive the apocalypse”).
Look, I get it Halloween can be chaotic. Between costumes, candy wrappers, sugar crashes, and that one kid who shows up an hour early… it’s a lot. But games like Who’s Most Likely To remind us that simple, shared moments often turn into the most magical memories.
So print this out, gather your crew, and let the laughter roll. You don’t need a Pinterest-perfect setup or a spooky mansion. All you need is a little imagination, some people you love, and a willingness to be a little ridiculous.
