Fall This or That
Fall This or That: A Simple Game for Big Seasonal Fun
There’s just something magical about fall, isn’t there? The cozy sweaters, the smell of cinnamon in the air, leaves crunching under your boots, and the promise of together time. Whether you’re a parent looking for an easy screen-free activity, a teacher planning a fun classroom break, or a host throwing a fall party This or That is a game that totally gets the season.
It’s super easy, doesn’t require any supplies (unless you want to print something cute), and everyone can join in from toddlers to grandparents. And the best part? It sparks the kind of conversations and giggles that make memories.
So grab a mug of something warm and let’s talk all things Fall This or That how to play, when to play, and loads of cozy question ideas to get you started.
What Is “This or That”?
“This or That” is a fast-paced, low-pressure game where someone reads out two fall-themed options, and everyone picks their favorite. That’s it! No keeping score (unless you want to). No pressure to be funny. Just lots of laughs and maybe a surprise or two when someone declares they hate pumpkin spice. (Gasp!)
Example:
- “Pumpkin Patch or Corn Maze?”
- “Hot Apple Cider or Pumpkin Spice Latte?”
- “Sweater Weather or Hoodie Season?”
Everyone simply says which one they’d rather choose. It’s fun, light, and completely adaptable to any setting. Plus, it’s a great way to get to know people better or just bond with your own family after a long day.
Why Fall Is the Perfect Season for This Game
Fall is the season of slowing down a bit bundling up, baking, gathering with friends and family. It naturally invites cozy conversations, warm drinks, and a little more time indoors. That’s why This or That works so well this time of year.
It’s the kind of simple game that feels just right on a chilly evening, during a Thanksgiving gathering, or while waiting for dinner to finish cooking.
No-Prep, No-Fuss Fun for Any Occasion
You don’t need fancy materials, a big group, or any setup time. Just a few fun questions and people willing to share their favorites.
You can play it:
- At the dinner table
- In the car on the way to the pumpkin patch
- During fall parties or harvest festivals
- While walking through crunchy leaves
- Snuggled up on the couch with your kids
- Or even in a classroom to break up the day!
It’s also a fantastic icebreaker for youth group events, club meetings, or even casual hangouts with friends.
Want to Make It Extra Cute and Party-Ready?
We’ve got a printable for that!
Check out this Thanksgiving This or That Game Printable. It’s ready to go and absolutely perfect for Thanksgiving tables, kids’ activities, or classroom fun. Just download, print, and let the fall fun begin!
Tons of Fall This or That Question Ideas
To get you started, here’s a big batch of fun questions you can ask. You can keep things silly, go deep, or mix it up depending on who you’re playing with.
Food Edition
- Apple pie or pumpkin pie?
- Hot chocolate or hot apple cider?
- Chili or butternut squash soup?
- Sweet treats or salty snacks?
- Halloween candy or Thanksgiving leftovers?
- Caramel apples or s’mores?
Outdoor Fun Edition
- Hayrides or corn mazes?
- Jumping in leaves or picking pumpkins?
- Scary haunted house or spooky movie?
- Hiking in the woods or a cozy picnic in the park?
- Raking leaves or making a leaf pile to jump in?
Fall Festivities
- Halloween party or Thanksgiving dinner?
- Trick-or-treating or trunk-or-treat?
- Fall craft night or baking day?
- Pumpkin carving or painting pumpkins?
- Visiting a farm or going to a fall festival?
Style & Vibe
- Sweater weather or hoodie season?
- Beanies or wide-brim hats?
- Ugg boots or fuzzy socks?
- Candles or essential oils?
- Cozy blanket or electric heater?
At-Home Cozy Time
- Reading a fall-themed book or watching a fall movie?
- Baking cookies or roasting marshmallows?
- Movie night or game night?
- Puzzles or coloring?
- Fireplace or fire pit?
And if you want even more cozy questions, take a peek at these two fun blog posts:
📌 Thanksgiving Would You Rather – great for older kids and adults!
📌 Fall Would You Rather Questions – packed with seasonal silliness and perfect for groups.
Want to Make It More Interactive? Try These Twists:
If you’re playing with a bigger group or want to add a little excitement, here are some fun twists to try:
1. Movement Game
Assign each answer a side of the room. Ask the question, and everyone walks to the side that matches their pick. Great for classrooms or active kiddos.
2. Speed Round
Challenge your group to answer 10 questions in a minute. No explanations, just gut reactions. It’s fast, funny, and gets everyone giggling.
3. Guess the Group
Before reading out the answers, try to guess which one will be the “crowd favorite.” See how well you know your people!
4. Pair & Share
Once everyone picks their answer, ask them to explain why. You’ll get everything from heartfelt memories to goofy stories. It’s great for bonding.
Where to Use This Game
This or That is like the Swiss Army knife of fall games it works everywhere. Try it:
- In the classroom – great for transition time or holiday fun
- At Thanksgiving – a calm activity while waiting for the food to finish
- During sleepovers – just enough structure to avoid the chaos
- While traveling – makes long drives to Grandma’s house fly by
- On chilly evenings – light a candle, sip something warm, and chat away
Why Families Keep Coming Back to This Game
As a parent, I know how hard it is to find a game that everyone enjoys and this one is a winner every single time. It works for all ages, sparks real conversation, and feels like a shared experience instead of just another activity to check off the list.
Kids feel heard, grown-ups feel connected, and no one’s stuck explaining 18-step board game rules. Sometimes, the simplest things bring the most joy. And that’s exactly what This or That does.
So, when the leaves start falling and your calendar starts filling up, tuck this little game in your back pocket. Fall This or That is an easy, joyful way to reconnect with the people you love whether you’re gathered around a dinner table, riding in a minivan, or just looking to make a chilly evening a little warmer.
Grab this Thanksgiving This or That Printable if you want something cute and ready to go. And don’t forget to check out our blog for more cozy game ideas like Fall Would You Rather and Thanksgiving Would You Rather.
